James Angelo's Underground Pizza

Discover James Angelo's Underground Pizza in Waimea, HI, offering authentic NY-style pizza, calzones, garlic knots, gluten-free options, and more. Enjoy homemade dough and flavorful dishes in a cash-only family-friendly setting.

View MenuContact

Welcome to James Angelo's Underground Pizza

Experience the finest dining

James Angelo's Underground Pizza
James Angelo's Underground Pizza
James Angelo's Underground Pizza
James Angelo's Underground Pizza

Nestled along the picturesque Hawai`i Belt Rd, James Angelo's Underground Pizza delivers a taste of New York right here in Waimea, HI. This cozy spot captures the charm of a classic pizzeria while offering a unique twist on traditional favorites. Visitors rave about the homemade meatballs, eggplant parmesan, and gluten-free options, making it a go-to for all pizza enthusiasts. Imagine a place where the dough is made fresh daily, and the aroma of garlic knots fills the air. Whether dining in or taking out, this restaurant promises a heartwarming culinary experience. Plus, it’s cash only, ensuring a quick and hassle-free payment process.

James Angelo's Underground Pizza shines with its extensive menu and friendly service. The restaurant features 29 delectable dishes, from 18" specialty pizzas to homemade desserts. Highlights include mouthwatering shrimp scampi pizza and a savory meatball calzone. Guests appreciate the variety of appetizers, including sweet BBQ chicken wings and cheesy garlic bread, perfect for sharing.

The casual interior invites families and friends to enjoy meals together. The ambiance is laid-back, enhancing the comfort of indulging in delicious pizza.

Peak times reveal a bustling atmosphere, especially on Tuesdays when the restaurant hits full capacity by 5 PM. So, those who want a quieter experience should aim for off-peak hours.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

64-974 Hawai`i Belt Rd, Waimea, HI 96743, United States

Phone

+1 808-885-7888

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

James Angelo's Underground Pizza
James Angelo's Underground Pizza
James Angelo's Underground Pizza
James Angelo's Underground Pizza

This pizzeria stands out in Waimea for its dedication to quality and tradition. Each dish begins with fresh homemade dough, crafted to perfection to produce that iconic NY-style crust. James Angelo's specializes in large 18" pizzas that cater to hearty appetites. Choices like the Meat Lovers and Veggie Lovers strike a perfect balance for any crowd.

The menu doesn’t stop at pizza; guests can enjoy hearty appetizers like garlic knots or sweet BBQ chicken wings, which never fail to impress.

The calzones are another crowd favorite, especially the chicken and eggplant parmesan options, stuffed generously with quality ingredients. And if you have a sweet tooth, their New York-style cheesecake and Sicilian-style cannoli round off the meal beautifully.

This eatery thrives on community spirit. Local residents and visitors alike come together to enjoy good food and great company. Waimea, known for its lush surroundings and vibrant community, makes this pizzeria a classic gathering spot.

Frequent diners often become familiar faces, sharing their pizza preferences and favorite memories. For those looking to create new experiences, James Angelo's offers a chance to immerse in the local dining scene while savoring unforgettable flavors. And with its commitment to offering gluten-free options, everyone can join in the fun.

James Angelo's Underground Pizza

James Angelo's sits conveniently along the scenic Hawai`i Belt Rd, with an inviting exterior that hints at the delicious offerings within. A colorful sign guides hungry diners in, while the building maintains a cozy, approachable vibe. Inside, the bustling atmosphere resonates with laughter and conversation, perfect for family gatherings or casual get-togethers with friends. The decor reflects the spirit of a classic New York pizzeria while staying true to the Hawaiian charm, making it a welcoming space for all.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday3-8:45 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday10:30 AM-8:45 PM
  • Wednesday10:30 AM-8:45 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM-8:45 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM-8:45 PM
  • Saturday10:30 AM-8:45 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

The owner was very hospitable and the gluten free pizza was great! It is a northeast coast style pizzeria like you would find in NJ/NY/MA. Try it, it's worth the drive from anywhere on the Big Island.

K
Kim M.

One of the best tasting, gluten free pizzas I've had. The service was great. If you're gluten free and staying on the Big Island, it's worth the drive from wherever you are staying.

S
Scott M.

Awesome little place coming from the North through Waimea. After a long day and drive through Volcano's National Park, this place hit the spot. ***CASH ONLY*** The two large Boston-style pizzas were delicious and filling. They also have a sonic crushed ice maker for their drinks! Great value and pricing for the whole family and there's a few tables to sit inside. Ample parking on the side. Will definitely return!

T
Travel C.

Oh, wow! What a beautiful pizza. I was so very much looking forward to trying this piece and it exceeded my expectations. If I lived on this island, I don't know why I would get pizza pie anywhere else. And homemade tiramisu, forget about it!

M
Mark B.

The best pizza in Hawaii! Worth a trip to Waimea for homemade crust made daily. The owner is James, originally from Boston. You may get to see him tossing the dough up in the air! It's a nice chewy and crunchy crust, it's really perfection. Toppings and cheese are generous portions and of course the sauce is delicious.

T
Tink L.

Great little pizza spot! Floor is slippery with flour dust, there's a giant table labeled "The Godfather" and they have pebble ice. Dude making pizza is no nonsense, little conversation but solid delivery. Pizza was fantastic! Check them out!

M
Mark B.